[vc_row content_placement=”top” row_space=”remove_padding_top”][vc_column][vc_column_text]
Dear Education Secretary,
Thank you for enabling all pupils to return to school on 8 March. Despite this, we have significant concerns about Government guidance recommending that children wear masks in classrooms.
This recommendation does not seem to be based on any scientific evidence, fails to recognise the new realities of us having offered the vaccine to the most vulnerable groups, appears to have been introduced without evaluation of potential harms, and significantly undermines the “national priority” of ensuring British schoolchildren have the education that they deserve.[/vc_column_text][vc_row_inner][vc_column_inner][vc_column_text]
As all the scientists keep telling us, the youngest are least affected by COVID-19. Yet last week the Children’s Commissioner reported that at least 850 million classroom days have been lost through school closures. The education recovery package and catch-up plans are hugely welcome, but your recommendation puts a huge confusing, and potentially harmful, impediment in the way of teachers who simply want to open their school gates and classrooms, teach our children and help pupils catch up after this devastating year.
Last Summer, the Government said masks in classrooms were unnecessary. The Prime Minister described it as “nonsensical” and said that “you can’t teach with face coverings and you can’t expect people to learn with face coverings.” Your own department’s August guidance said that they “can have a negative impact on learning and teaching and so their use in the classroom should be avoided.”
By 15 February, the NHS had vaccinated the top four most at risk groups – groups that have accounted for around 88% of COVID-19 deaths and about 55% of hospitalisations. The UK’s four Chief Medical Officers say that you get “substantial protection within 2-3 weeks of vaccination”, which takes us to 8 March. So upon what evidence is your department relying in order to recommend that masks in classrooms are today necessary – rather than “nonsensical” – now that the four most vulnerable groups have “substantial protection”?
There appears to have been little or no consideration given to any of the negative outcomes of facemasks being worn in classrooms all day. The WHO places responsibilities on authorities recommending face masks for children requiring the “monitoring and evaluation…measuring the impact on the child’s health, including mental health”. Can you reassure us that an evaluation by either DfE or DHSC took place before this latest recommendation was made?[/vc_column_text][/vc_column_inner][/vc_row_inner][vc_column_text]Pupils all over the country have had a devastating year. We need teachers to be able to teach, not to be held back by confusing Government recommendations. Schools and teachers across the country will have to spend all their time enforcing these rules, performing their own cost-benefit analysis, and managing parents’ concerns about mask wearing, when we need them focusing on teaching.
Schools are not vectors of transmission. You yourself said back in August that “one of the largest studies on the coronavirus in schools in the world” made it “clear there is little evidence that the virus is transmitted at school”. Professor Chris Whitty this week said that “the risk to children is incredibly low from going to school and, indeed, from catching Covid”. And the Prime Minister told the nation on 27 January that “the problem is not that schools are unsafe – teachers and headteachers have worked heroically to make sure they are safe, they are Covid-secure.”
If you wish to keep this recommendation in place, please publish the new scientific evidence which makes this measure necessary – especially in light of the vaccination rollout – and show the evidence that this intervention has been properly evaluated for potential harms to both psychological and physical health, so that schools can make an informed decision about whether or not to follow Government guidance, and so that parents and pupils can have confidence in the measure your department is recommending. Otherwise, your department should reverse it.
Yours sincerely,[/vc_column_text][vc_row_inner][vc_column_inner][vc_column_text]Selected Signatories
Academics
Professor Alan Floyd Professor of Education, Reading University
Professor Anthony Fryer Professor of Clinical Biochemistry, Keele University
Professor David Paton Professor of Industrial Economics, Nottingham University
Professor David Seedhouse Professor of Deliberative Practice, Aston University
Professor Dennis Hayes Emeritus Professor of Education, University of Derby
Professor Ellen Townsend Professor of Psychology, Nottingham University
Professor Ellie Lee Professor of Family and Parenting Research, University of Kent
Professor Karol Sikora Oncologist and Founding Dean, Medicine School, University of Buckingham
Professor Martin Neil Professor of Statistics and Computer Science, Queen Mary, London
Professor Matthew Ratcliffe Professor of Philosophy (Mental Health), University of York
Professor Marilyn James Professor of Health Economics, Nottingham University
Professor Nicola Pitchford Professor of Developmental Psychology, Nottingham University
Professor Richard Ennos Honorary Professional Fellow, Biological Sciences, University of Edinburgh
Professor Robert Dingwall Professor in the School of Social Sciences, Nottingham Trent University
Professor Robert Endres Professor, Biological Physics., Imperial College, London
Professor Robert Sauer Chair of Economics, Royal Holloway, University of London
Professor Sarah J Lewis Professor of Molecular Epidemiology, University of Bristol
Professor Sunetra Gupta Professor of Theoretical Epidemiology, Oxford University
Professor Victoria Shingler Professor of Molecular Biology, Umea University
Dr Lee Jones University Lecturer, Queen Mary, University of London
Dr Jade Norris Senior Research Analyst Autism Research, Bristol University
Dr Paul King Lecturer, Biological Sciences, Birkbeck University
Dr Pedro Parreira Lecturer in Physics, Glasgow University
Dr Ruth Mieschbuehler Senior Lecturer in Education Studies, University of Derby
Dr Sebastien Viatte Lecturer in Genetics, University of Manchester
Dr Tanya Klymenko Lecturer in Biochemistry, Sheffield Hallam University
Dr Tom Jefferson Physician Researcher
Jonathan Berry Clinical Lecturer, Keele University
David Ridley Senior Lecturer in Physical Education, Sheffield Hallam University[/vc_column_text][vc_column_text]
Public Figures
Tim Henman Tennis Professional
Baron Moonie (Lewis) Retired consultant in public health, and politician
Lord Sumption Retired judge
Baroness Morrissey (Helena) Company Director and member of House of Lords
Lee Hurst Not Allowed To Work Comedian
Matthew Le Tissier Self employed
Richard Madeley Journalist
Sue Cook Writer and broadcaster
David Perks Headteacher
Anthea Turner Media
Adam Brooks Publican
Alexander Starling Company Director
Allison Pearson Journalist and Author
Bob Moran Journalist
Calvin Robinson Political adviser
Dan Astin-Gregory Entrepreneur
Dr Zoe Harcombe Author & Researcher
Emma Sayle CEO
Francis Hoar Barrister
Gillian Mckeith Television Presenter, Nutritionist and Author
Graham Hutchinson Previously Senior Chief Biomedical Scientist, Colindale.
Hugh Osmond Director
Ian Seale Actor
Joanna Williams Journalist
Carol McGiffin Broadcaster and Writer
Laurence Fox Politician
Julia Hartley-Brewer TalkRadio presenter
Laura Dodsworth Writer
Laura Perrins Journalist
James Delingpole Journalist
Michael Yeadon Retired, former R&D consultant Biotechnology & Life Sciences
Martin Daubney Editorial Director, Unlocked
Richard Tice Director
Robin Monotti Graziadei Architect
Sonia Elijah Journalist
Sonia Poulton Journalist
Tonia Buxton TV Presenter & Author
William Clouston Party Leader, The Social Democratic Party
Mark Dolan Broadcaster
Dominique Samuels Political Commentator
Peter Hitchens Journalist and Author
Anna Brees Journalist
Alexander Adams Author[/vc_column_text][/vc_column_inner][/vc_row_inner][vc_row_inner][vc_column_inner width=”1/2″][vc_column_text]Medical, Scientific and Mental Health Professionals
Alida Nel Medical Doctor
C.Geoffrey Maidment Consultant Physician (retired)
Clare Craig Medical Doctor
Charlotte Bell Immunologist and Veterinary Surgeon
Christine Suppelt Doctor
Christopher Paul Chilton Retired Consultant Urologist
Dr Alan Mordue Public Health Doctor
Dr Brian Hands Retired GP
Dr David Morris General Practitioner
Dr David Critchley Clinical Research Scientist
Dr Deborah Tattersall Consultant Radiologist
Dr Elizabeth Corcoran Doctor
Dr Fiona Martindale GP
Dr Helen Westwood GP
Dr Jon Rogers Retired GP
Dr Michelle Morters Vet and Epidemiologist
Dr. Philip George Hollywood Retired Consultant in Anaesthesia
Dr Renée Hoenderkamp GP
Dr Ricky Freeman GP
Dr Rosamond A K Jones Consultant Paediatrician (retired)
Dr Ross Worthington BM BCh
Ian Comaish Surgeon
Ivan Trotman Doctor
James Royle Consultant Cancer Surgeon
Jai Chitnavis Medical Doctor
Malcolm Loudon Consultant Surgeon
Patrick Walsh Consultant Surgeon (Retired)
Pauline Jones Retired GP
Redvers Cording Retired Dental Surgeon
Rupert Mason MBBS, LRCP, MRCS
Andy Halewood Psychologist
Camellia Kojouri Psychologist
Dr Elias Diamantis Liaison Psychiatrist
Dr Faye Bellanca Child Clinical Psychologist
Dr Harrie Bunker-Smith Clinical Psychologist
Dr Damian Wilde Highly Specialist Clinical Psychologist
Dr Tom Carnworth Psychiatrist
Dr Zenobia Storah Clinical Psychologist
Dr. Rachel Mahoney Clinical Psychologist
Dr. Bruce Scott Psychoanalyst
Jo Cullen Psychologist and educationalist
Lauren McCoy Psychologist
Naomi Murphy Clinical Psychologist
Heidi Stone Consultant Positive Psychologist
Leigh Jones Clinical psychologist
Gary Sidley Retired Clinical Psychologist
Elizabeth Bentley Psychotherapist
Gillian Rock Retired psychotherapist
Josephine Patten-Walsh Psychotherapist
Kayleigh Morrison Psychotherapist
Kate James Psychotherapist
Lorraine Valentine Psychotherapist
Richard Rowland Psychotherapist
Shereena Hamilton NHS Children’s Mental Health Support Worker
Amanda Cairns Occupational Health Nurse
Alex Penfold Nurse
Chantel Greenwood Nurse
Claire Ganley Occupational Health Nurse
Diane Macgregor RGN, Nurse Practitioner
Danielle Ashe Nurse
Elspeth Hill Paediatric nurse
Emma King Paediatric nurse & Health visitor
Emma Greenslade School Nurse
Ealeorah Ravleen Nurse
James Fair Nurse
Johanna Hubbard Retired nurse
Julia Harding Nurse
Julia Desousa Registered Nurse
Katie Richards Nurse
Katherine Hooper Retired nurse specialist/paediatric
Lesley Collins Retired RN
Leanne Ludlow Staff nurse
Lisa Henderson Nurse
Louise Smith Registered Nurse
Lucy Richards Nurse
Luke Knight Nurse
Michael Cockayne Occupational Health Nurse Practitioner
Nicola McQuaid Retired Staff Nurse
Peter Roberts Nurse
Roisin Bradley Nurse
Sheila Skipworth Retired Midwife/Nurse
Steve Dean Nurse
Susan Martin Nurse
Suzanne France Nurse
Timothy Adams Staff nurse
Leona Jupe Paramedic
Darren Smith Paramedic
Annabel Acheson-Gray Physiotherapist
Tanya Croall Physiotherapist
Jo Rogers Occupational Therapist
Teresa Harding NHS Health Care Assistant
Natalia James NHS Manager
Angela Taylor NHS Psychological Therapist
Fiona MacCallum NHS Worker
Peter March NHS Worker
Gregory Lynn NHS Worker
Anna Rayner Health Professional
Colin Cambray Microbiologist
Colin Knaggs Microbiologist.
Cristina Roadevin Health Economist
David M Livermore Microbiologist
Dr Alvin Milner Consultant Biostatistician
Gerry Quinn Microbiologist
Rachel Nicoll Medical Researcher
Richard Allread Bio pharmaceutical Development Director
Samantha Fallon Analytical Chemist
[/vc_column_text][/vc_column_inner][vc_column_inner width=”1/2″][vc_column_text]Education and Children’s Services Professionals
Annabel Nicolls Academy Trust Sponsor
David Perks Headteacher
Pauline Wood Educational Consultant and former Headteacher
Zoe Staines Deputy Headteacher
Alex Stapaj Assistant Head of Year
Raymond French Vice Principal (Rtd)
Adrian Baker Teacher of Physics
Alastair Burr School Teacher Secondary
Amanda Britton Teacher
Josephine Hussey Teacher
Adele Stevens Teacher
Adrian Dulston Teacher
Alec Lee Teacher
Alison Wormald Retired teacher
Amy Harman Teacher
Angela Dobric Teacher
Ann Parry Teacher
Anna Fauzy-Ackroyd Retired primary school teacher
Anna Dunham Secondary school teacher
Andreana Ashby Secondary Teacher
Andrew Wilson Teacher (retired)
Catherine Edwards Teacher
Christa Swain Teacher / director
Claire Braisdell Teacher
Claire Emery Teacher
Claire Souter Teacher
Colette Rowley Teacher
Dave Wardle Retired Teacher (Head of Faculty)
Daniel Caffarey Teacher
Dawn Fletcher Teacher (SEN)
Denise Wood Retired teacher
Edward Casey Retired teacher
Dr Sophie Messager Teacher
Fatema Paretha Teacher
Fiona Beddow Teacher
Fraser Stark Teacher
Gavin Welch Teacher (Sixth Form)
Georgina Jones Teacher
Harrison Thompson Teacher
Hayley Compton Teacher
Helen Backhouse Teacher
Jacqueline Webb Teacher
Jane Hall Teacher
Jenny Pollock Teacher
Jenny Knapton Supply teacher
Jessica Elms Teacher
John Duffy Teacher
Karanjot Panesar Teacher
Karen Connell Teacher
Kathryn Napier Teacher
Katie Howarth Teacher
Kathryn Keigher Retired teacher
Kay Measor M.A.(Ed) Retired teacher
Judith Hawarden Retired teacher
Louli Money Retired teacher
Laurie wood Teacher
Louise Newby Science Teacher
Madeleine Gillies Teacher
Maeve Keenan Teacher
Mark Baker Teacher
Mel Brown Teacher
Michael Stokes Teacher
Natalie Duncan Teacher
Nicole Gibbs Teacher
Phillip Dixon Teacher
Rebecca D’Cruz Teacher
Robert Willson Teacher
Samantha Savage Teacher
Sarah Hall Teacher
Sian Hutchinson Teacher
Stephen Martin Teacher
Susan Mathewson Teacher
Teresa Ruiz Blanco Teacher
Tim Jones Teacher
Tim Arden-White Supply Teacher
Valerie Carter Teacher
Zoe Nicolaou Teacher
Julie Green Teacher
Sarita cameron Teacher
Toby Marshall Teacher
Emma Farquharson Teacher
Emma Flourentzou Teacher
Emma Poulton Teacher
Helen White Teacher
Katie Stark Teacher
Michelle Cooper Teacher
M K Wilson Retired teacher
Nathalie Franklin Teacher
Nina Evans Teacher
Ortal Wolfson Teacher
Padraic Flynn Teacher
Paul Robotham Retired Teacher
Rebecca Attwood Teacher
Robert Horan Teacher
Rhoda Margaret Anderton Retired Teacher
S Wiltshire Teacher
Sara Fanner Teacher
Sarah caley Teacher
Sharon Stanley Retired Teacher
Sonia Dignum Teacher
Talga Bendie Teacher
Trisch Knight Retired Teacher
Angela Voon Teacher
Brankica Bokan-Tomic Teacher
Catherine Edwards Teacher
Claire Rushworth Teacher
Claire Souter Teacher
David Ylla Teacher
Elizabeth Robertson Teacher
Emma Farquharson Teacher
Fraser stark Teacher
Georgina Jones Teacher
Gillian Barham Teacher
Hayley Compton Teacher
Helen Backhouse Teacher
James Trubridge Teacher
Jayne Dickerson Teacher
Jessica Elms Teacher
Joanna Clarke Teacher
John Teacher
John Duffy Teacher
Justin Noutch Teacher
Kathryn Napier Teacher
Katie Fox Teacher
Katie Howarth Teacher
Katie Stark Teacher
Marcus Bailey Teacher
Mariam Zaidi Teacher
Martin Davies Teacher
Michelle Cooper Teacher
Nathalie Franklin Teacher
Phillip Dixon Teacher
Rebecca Attwood Teacher
Robert Horan Teacher
Robert Pokorny Teacher
Sara Fanner Teacher
Sarah Harrison Teacher
Seamus Rush Teacher
Simon Holloway Teacher
Sonia Dignum Teacher
Stephen Martin Teacher
Susanna Verde Teacher
Talga Bendie Teacher
Valerie Carter Teacher
John McHugh EFL Teacher
Clare Holland Teaching assistant
Karen Strain Teaching Assistant
Kathy Ganachaud Teaching Assistant
Thaira Malik Teaching Assistant
Anette Gould Teaching assistant
Jill Wilford Teaching Assistant
Joanna Burton Teaching Assistant
Lesley Chan Special educational needs assistant (mainstream secondary)
Michelle Staff Teaching assistant
Nicola Hughes Teaching assistant
Nora Pearson Teaching Assistant
Paula Foran Teaching assistant
Sharon Strange Retired Teaching Assistant
Vikki Bradbury Teaching assistant
Paula Thompson Teaching assistant/EFT Practitioner
Carol Skyte Retired Nursery Assistant
Patsy Collinson Early Childhood Educator
Karen Woods Early years educator
Victoria Pratt Early years educator
Amy Boyd Early years practitioner
Laura Kelsey Early Years Professional
Karen Woods Early years educator
Victoria Pratt Early years educator
Amy Boyd Early years practitioner
Saeira Salim Montessori Teacher
Jo Carmichael Montessori Teacher
Michelle Todd Nursery nurse
H Heppenstall Nursery Nurse
Jennifer Metcalf NNEB Dip. Nursery Nurse
Claire Williams Nursery Practitioner
Samantha Stevens Special Needs Carer, Nanny
Natalie Webster Nursery Teacher
Yvonne Jack Nursery Manager
Catherine Harker Ret. Speech therapist
Anthony Dalton Education
B Roberts Education
Gayle Harper-Smith Education
Michael Romaniw Education
Helena R Marilican Education
Rosy Dickinson Education
Sarah Ferdinands Education Consultant in HX/EX (ex-teacher)
Lance Burkitt Education Manager
Jasmina Haigh Education professional
Bernadette Donegan Education Support Administrator
Ruth Cherrington Educational Consultant
Jacqueline Donovan Educator
Karina Morrison Bell Educator
Jonathan Cubitt School Bursar
Katie Windle School Chaplain
Janie Dimopoulos School counsellor
Janine Gumm School counsellor
Victoria Holland SEND and Safeguarding Administrator
Jennifer Wild Student Support Adviser
Helena Meser Social Worker
Tara Webb Social worker
Victoria Swift Social worker
Carla Jamieson Residential childcare officer
[/vc_column_text][/vc_column_inner][/vc_row_inner][/vc_column][/vc_row]